Habs Mailbag: Canadiens Lineup Choices, Xhekaj, Trades, Waivers

Welcome back to the weekly edition of the off-season Montreal Canadiens Mailbag.

This week we discuss Jesse Ylonen’s chances of making the opening-night roster, the enforcer situation in the Atlantic Division, the possibility of trading some of the overpaid veterans, prospects, special teams, and much more.

Let’s get right into it!

Is Ylonen making the team out of camp?

— Mike (@HabsLaughs) July 31, 2023

A lot of the opening-night roster questions hinge on whether Christian Dvorak will be deemed healthy enough to return to the lineup.

If he is indeed healthy, the spots up front will be hard to come by for fringe players.

In my most recent projected lineup for the Canadiens, I have Michael Pezzetta, Rem Pitlick, and Chris Wideman in the minors, which allows Ylonen to avoid waivers.

It would be understandable to go to bat for Pezzetta in this situation, especially since he’s a hard-working player that brings a sneaky amount of value to the lineup, but given the Habs are desperate for shooting talent and Ylonen has one of the best shots in the organization, it would be foolish to ignore what the 23-year-old Finn brings to the table.

Let’s remind ourselves that Ylonen put up a 13-goal, 23-assist pro-rated scoring pace last season (82 games), a very solid production rate when we consider he only received an average of 12 minutes per game at 5v5.

Of course, Kent Hughes could make room for both Pezzetta and Ylonen by trading one of his overpaid forwards, but that will be a rather tall task.

More on that later.

The other wildcard in the Ylonen equation is Emil Heineman. Ylonen is much better in his own zone, but Heineman was fantastic during his time with the Laval Rocket last year, and he also provides a boost to the lineup when it comes to shooting talent. If he manages to stand out at training camp as he did in 2022, there’s a slight chance he could edge out a player like Ylonen for the 12th or 13th spot in the lineup.

Do you think Habs fans tend to overrate Xhekaj as an NHLer due to his big personality and physical game? I love the player, but I have a hard time seeing him becoming more than a 3rd pairing defenseman throughout his career.

— Wade Messier (@wade_messier) July 31, 2023

I think for the most part, Habs fans are well aware of what Arber Xhekaj brings to the lineup, as well as his potential.

He was one of the best stories in the NHL last season, and there’s no doubt his entertaining style of play has led to him quickly becoming a fan favourite, but I don’t see many people pencilling him into the top-4 when it comes to projected rosters. The vast majority of the lineups I have seen have him on the third pairing.

And that’s absolutely fine.

We have to remember that Xhekaj is the only player in the history of the NHL to go undrafted as a defenceman and then make the jump directly from the CHL to the NHL.

Getting a single shift from him in the NHL should be considered a huge win. The fact that the Canadiens did not even have to use a draft pick to secure his services is just about as good as it gets when it comes to low-cost asset acquisitions.

Of course, some tend to overrate him, just as there are some that tend to underrate him, but in this case, I think the majority of Habs fans are just happy to see an affable, entertaining, and physically dominant defenceman in the lineup.

It also helps that he would probably win a tug-of-war with an M4 Sherman.

If you were Kent Hughes, would you try and trade for someone who can handle themselves well, seeings that both Boston and Toronto beefed up? (Reeves and Lucic). Mainly so Arber’s got some reinforcements! If I had my way I’d bring back Deslauriers!

— 𝙃𝙊𝘾𝙆𝙀𝙔 𝙉𝙄𝙂𝙃𝙏 𝙄𝙉 𝙈𝙊𝙉𝙏𝙍𝙀𝘼𝙇 🏒 (@HNIMtl) July 31, 2023

Personally, I wouldn’t worry about those two, at all, for a couple of reasons.

The first reason is that both Ryan Reaves and Milan Lucic are on the wrong side of 35 years old, and enforcers tend to see a sharp decline in playing minutes at that point in their careers.

Actually, it’s already happened. They were given an average of 10:55 and 9:20 in average 5v5 ice time last season, respectively. It’s also worth noting that both players had awful underlying numbers relative to their teammates last season, which means they’re a huge drag on their team.

Boston and Toronto will want to compete for a playoff spot, and they’ll quickly figure out that playing their enforcers is not conducive to getting positive results.

The second is that I don’t believe Arber Xhekaj is under the impression that he needs to fight all challengers next season. He addressed the situation toward the end of the season, and he confirmed that he’ll have to pick and choose his fights a little more wisely during his sophomore season.

He knows that when it comes to fisticuffs he has nothing to prove anymore, and it’s the right approach given how the division is shaping up for next season.

If there’s a situation that arises naturally, he may end up dropping the gloves with either Lucic or Reaves, but I doubt he’ll want to engage in any staged fights. He has nothing to gain.

What are the chances of moving Armia, Dvorak or Hoffman or Wideman before the trade deadline?

— Cliveww (@Cliveww3) July 31, 2023

For now, little to none.

Mike Hoffman has been offered to every NHL club, for free. There were no takers. Joel Armia has one of the worst contracts in the league when you consider his production, and Chris Wideman currently has a negative trade value.

I maintain there’s still a non-zero chance that Christian Dvorak may end up having some sort of trade value, but it’ll take a very solid start to the season to remove the negative impression he’s made in Montreal since Marc Bergevin panicked and overpaid the Arizona Coyotes to acquire him.

That also applies to Hoffman. If he gets off to a hot start, his goal-scoring prowess could lead to an offer or two, but even with a red-hot start, the return would be minimal.

Simply put, don’t get your hopes up that Kent Hughes will be able to move one of his overpaid veterans without paying teams to absorb the contract.

That’s not something he’s interested in doing at this stage of the rebuild.

Which #GoHabsGo prospect are you most excited to watch?

— Casey Leigh (@Casey_LeighD) July 31, 2023

My go-to answer to this question is always Adam Engstrom. He was fantastic in his rookie year for Rogle, and he should be given top-pairing ice time next season.

And then there’s Lane Hutson, who epitomizes excitement.

MUST READ: Lane Hutson Shatters All Expectations In Rookie NCAA Season

But since I’ve discussed their potential at length in recent months, I’ll pivot a little and suggest Joshua Roy’s transition to professional hockey should be of great interest to all Canadiens fans.

He’s one of the only prospects that will have a legitimate chance of earning an NHL roster spot next year, even though the odds are not in his favour.

There are simply too few roster spots available, especially up front, and I think players like Heineman and Ylonen have the inside track. But Roy’s well-rounded game, which includes great defensive play, is definitely an ace up his sleeve when we consider the competition

Do you expect any improvement in the special teams department this season?

— J (@JMcinthe613) July 31, 2023

I’m an optimist by nature, but let’s consider the facts here.

The Canadiens had awful special teams last season.

The Canadiens will head into the 2023-24 campaign with essentially the same lineup as they did last season.

The Canadiens have the same coaches in charge of the special teams.

Ipso facto, there are good odds they’ll struggle on the penalty kill and power play once again.

Health will be a factor, but you’d be hard-pressed to suggest the players who replaced their injured brethren on the special teams played poorly. If anything, it seemed like the Canadiens enjoyed an improvement in their special-teams success rates once half the roster was injured.

I've seen a certain Habs site rank Lias Anderson over guys like Kapenen and Trudeau on NHL poential. Kind of confussed me.
Is there more to him then a AHLer at this point?

— Jay (@JKlitsgaard) July 31, 2023

I don’t rate Oliver Kapanen very highly, but it would be ridiculous to suggest Lias Anderson, who is four years old, has more NHL potential at this point.

Out of the three, I’d actually suggest that William Trudeau has the best chance of earning a job in the NHL. I see him projected as a reliable third-pairing defenceman thanks to his good decision-making and his well-rounded game, whereas I’m not sure Kapanen has the offensive instincts needed to thrive.

The Canadiens already have too many forwards who are defensive specialists, both in the NHL and in their prospect pool. And most of them have more offensive talent than Kapanaen.

As for Anderson, again, he’s 24 years old and has had a few kicks at the can already. He could end up playing a few games with the Habs if the injury bug returns, but for now, he’s simply a good player intended to bolster the Laval Rocket lineup.

Why do I feel like it’s gonna be Roy vs Heineman vs Ylonen for that final spot… #Armia

— Dachter M.D (@HutsonBaeCompny) July 31, 2023

I didn’t include Pezzetta in my opening-night lineup, but he will be in the mix.

The team likes his style of play, and both Hughes and Jeff Gorton have mentioned at length that they like icing a team with size and truculence.

Plus, keeping a player like Pezzetta in the lineup means prospects such as Roy and Heineman will be getting precious minutes in the AHL rather than toiling on the fourth line in the NHL.

Waivers also come into play, though, in my opinion, there’s very little chance Ylonen would be claimed, and even lower odds when it comes to Pezzetta.

When it comes down to it, Pezzetta vs. Ylonen is likely to be among the ‘big’ decisions at camp, and as always, I tend to err on the side of talent when it comes to roster decisions.

Ideally, Hughes would trade a veteran to make space for both in the Canadiens lineup, but as we’ve already discussed, that’s not an easy proposal.

With the long weekend coming up in Ontario, what's the best song to get the vibes started on a roadtrip?

— Melissa Leigh (she/they) (@MochiMayhem89) July 31, 2023

Before we get to the final question, I’d like to thank Melissa for submitting non-hockey questions every week. It allows me to rant about music, food, or life and general, which is always appreciated.

Also, before we jump into the subject in earnest, I’d like to remind everyone I haven’t listened to much new music. Or rather, I’ve listened to about 16 new songs since the late 90s.

I’m not saying new music is bad, but I’m definitely out of touch with current trends.

The first song on a proper road trip must always be ‘Don’t Stop Me Now‘ by Queen. That is not up for debate.

I’d follow it up with a little ‘Radar Love‘ by Golden Earring to set help set the tone.

After that, it’s all about having fun, and that’s all about having songs that get the good vibes running high.

It could be stuff like Feeling This, Monkey Wrench, The Rubberband Man (one of my favourite songs of all time), Video Killed The Radio Star, Mr.BlueSky, What I Got, Mr. Jones, Shine A Light, Today, El Scorcho, ABC, or anything else that’s fairly popular and will lead to everyone belting the song at the top of their lungs.

No one likes ‘deep cuts’ during a road trip.  Keep it popular, and keep it fun. Cater to your audience. Keep the 32-minute live version of a John Bonham drum solo for another day.

It’s Bob Marley‘s time to shine. And don’t hesitate to invite Toots and the Maytals to the party.

If you’re in my car, you’re probably going to end up listening to a fair bit of Canadiana. It always starts with Anne Murray, and then it includes songs like Grace Too, The Day We Hit The Coast, Giant, Sensory Deprivation, Home For A Rest, Used To Be Alright, Je Joue De La Guitare, Saskatchewan, Le Plombier, and, of course, The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down.

Oh, and try to mix in a little Jurassic 5, De La Soul, Mos Def, Blackalicious, Outkast, Tupac, A Tribe Called Quest, Notorious B.I.G., KRS-One, Cypress Hill, Snoop Dogg, and other classics if you can. Wu-Tang is optional, but as always, strongly recommended.

Motown/Soul/Funk is also a great choice.

Anything from the Four Tops, Otis Redding, Martha and the Vandellas, Marvin Gaye, Smokey Robinson, the Supremes, Mavis Staples, Bill Withers, Stevie Wonder, Curtis Mayfield or Sam Cooke should fit the bill.