Canadiens Analysis
Canadiens Kirby Dach Injury Is An Important Reality Check
The Kirby Dach injury will have repercussions throughout the Montreal Canadiens organization.
He’s the glue that keeps the middle of the roster together. His skill in transition is unmatched on the team, which explains why he immediately improves the underlying numbers of any teammate who is lucky enough to be placed on his line.
Losing him for the entire year will clearly hurt the team’s chances.
But it’s also an opportunity for the Canadiens to take stock of their current situation.
Injury Situation
As disheartening as it is to lose an important player like Dach at such an early point in the season, it’s definitely a reality check for a team like the Montreal Canadiens that is hoping to take the next step.
And if the Canadiens cannot handle losing a player who has yet to reach 50 points in his career, there are bigger issues at play.
It goes beyond the injury woes that have followed the team like an old-world curse.
Every team has injuries, and good teams can survive after losing an important player.
The Canadiens aren’t at that point.
Losing Dach essentially destabilizes their top nine because there is not enough offensive talent to make up for the loss of a single player. And we’re not talking about a Gabriel Landeskog type of player. With all due respect to Dach, he’s a very good player but has not crossed the threshold that would lead to analysts describing him as elite, at least not yet.
Looking Forward
The one thing that Dach managed to do best was produce healthy underlying numbers.
The Canadiens struggle to control the puck in high-danger areas, and they’re almost always outshot by their opponents, except when Dach is on the ice.
Now that he’s expected to miss the remainder of the season, we’ll get a better idea of which players need to be supported by Dach to generate encouraging stats, as well as which players can stand on their own.
It will also impact the Canadiens’ odds, and I’m not talking about their playoff odds.
Realistically, the team is still far from competing for the playoffs. Rather, I’m discussing draft lottery odds.
Adding high-end offensive at the draft is in order for a team like the Canadiens.
The good news is, much like the 2023 Draft, the 2024 Draft is once again loaded with forwards who project as elite. Players such as Cole Eiserman, Macklin Celebrini, and Ivan Demidov.
Unequivocally, without a shadow of a doubt, Ivan Demidov has the best hands in the #2024NHLDraft. pic.twitter.com/3D1r8f3a1X
— Hadi Kalakeche (@HadiK_Scouting) October 17, 2023
The injury to Dach is unfortunate, and there’s reason to believe he was poised for a big year, but it’s also a good time to be honest about the status of the team’s rebuild.
More than ever, it’s clear the Canadiens still have a lot of work to do before we can start discussing them as a team that’s ready to compete.
Five Canadiens Players Who Have Improved Or Slowed Down
Canadiens Game 22: Montembeault Starts, Armia Enters Lineup
Top Three Montreal Canadiens Players Likely To Be Traded First
Habs Daily: Corey Perry Situation, Price Motivates Future Stars
Canadiens Carey Price Serving As A Mentor To Stars Of Tomorrow
Canadiens Prospect Power Rankings: Mesar and Hutson Dominate
Habs Daily: Trading Goaltenders, Top Line Questions, Newhook
Habs Daily: Canadiens Prospect Rankings, Goalie Trade Talk
Habs Wrap: Rebuild Needs, Mesar Shines, Canadiens Trades
Taught the defense would be significantly better this season, boy was i wrong. Savard is terrible, harris is softer then my paper towel, ghule is injury proned. Kovacevic has been average, so is matheson. Only xhekaj has been good so far
It looks like Savard is playing on a slower gear.
Seens like another draft lotery pick, great news if you ask me !
Why so they can go off thw board and pick another defenseman. Or find excuses that elite talent offensive players dont fit “our” mold.. the dach injury and now heineman guhle and reinbacher shows this group has bigger issues. Do a better job at dwveloping. Tall lanky guys tend to get injured easier. Every championship team has elite forwards..and the habs have made bad picks over and over again. Any team that would have a 1st overall 2 3rd overalls and a 5th overall in a span of 10 years would be competitive by now
Not all sucky seasons coincide with good can’t-miss superstar draft talent depth. See: Yakapov, Stefan, Daigle, Lafrenierre…
Given Habs first and 5th picks you mention are just in the last two years… You’re asking for a lot of instant gratification.
The entire organization from the very top down is made up of rookies in their respective roles and it kinda shows imo
There are now questions about Dach’s durability. But the more I look at the Tinordi hit on Dach, the more I question the end result. Given the way injuries are most often treated in the NHL, I believe he may have already been playing with an injured knee (partial tear, whatever…) and was perhaps unable to absorb the impact -which was high and not directly involving the lower body – because of that. Just look at other players in the lineup such as Monahan, Gallagher, Pearson….young men by most standards, banged up and compromised to the point they require multiple surgeries to walk and function normally, never mind play to their potential. This is a huge problem that should not be blamed on the player. In boxing, a doctor checks each fighter before they get into the ring. Players should be checked in a similar fashion. If you cant make certain movements and don’t have full amplitude – or have to play with braces, etc., you probably shouldn’t be on the ice. The NHL is negligent in this respect.