Connect with us

Montreal Canadiens

Canadiens & Oilers Linked In Trade Chatter, But Not For Monahan



Canadiens defenceman Joel Edmundson

The Montreal Canadiens and the Edmonton Oilers have been linked by many this past week, but it’s seemingly not for Sean Monahan.

The Edmonton Oilers need a little bit of everything in their lineup, but their most dire need is a veteran defenceman capable of logging big minutes and rising to the opportunity during the playoffs.

The Montreal Canadiens traded such a player in Ben Chiarot to the Florida Panthers last summer in exchange for an impressive package, and they have another one possibly available this spring in Joel Edmundson.

A former Cup-winner with the St-Louis Blues, Edmundson was also part of the top-four defensive group that powered the Canadiens to a Stanley Cup Final just two years ago.

His 48 playoff games in the last five years make him a prime candidate to come in and balance a team’s defensive corps, and there is likely no defensive unit more in need of stabilizing than that of the Edmonton Oilers.

On a recent episode of the Got Yer Back podcast, TSN reporter Ryan Rishaug has The Athletic’s Arpon Basu on to talk about the obvious fit Joel Edmundson would be on the Oilers’ blueline and what it would cost to get him in Edmonton.

Basu points out that, given General Manager Kent Hughes’ desire to acquire another 1st round pick, outside of Monahan, Edmundson could be his best way of getting it done.

“Their plan was to add another first-round pick, but how they were going to do that wasn’t clear,” said Basu regarding Hughes’ plan to secure a third 1st round pick.  “They had three guys that were coming up on expiring contracts and Monahan is the one that might come close to getting them that, but I doubt it. But if you get two playoff runs out of Joel Edmundson, the Canadiens might be in a position to go get that.”

The reasoning is that Basu feels the Ben Chiarot trade has set the market for second-pair defencemen with prime playoff experience at the trade deadline, being that of a 1st round pick.

“If things go the way I expect them to go, I wouldn’t be surprised if someone like Joel Edmundson would be available, but that (a 1st round pick) is going to be the price tag,” said Basu regarding what he thinks the value fo Edmundson could be. “Seeing what Ben Chiarot fetched on the open market, I would think the conversation would start there.”

That being said, Basu believes that some teams may be more reluctant than most years to give up their 1st round selection, given the strength of the 2023 NHL Draft class.

Instead, Basu believes the Canadiens may forgo the acquisition of a 1st round pick in favour of a former 1st round pick that may be just as valuable and further along in their development.

“The quality of this draft class is what’s going to make it difficult,” said Basu regarding Hughes’ desire for a third 1st round pick. “I think a lot of teams think that, even if you’re picking in the 20s, this is a year that you could get a good player. It’s very possible the 1st round pick is not available, in which case the Canadiens could ask for a former 1st round pick.”

The player that was brought up by Rishaug as a potential option was none other than Xavier Bourgault, whom has been confirmed to be on Hughes’ radar over the past year.

A deal centered around Bourgault and Edmundson, with other pieces involved to even out salary and value, would be an absolute win for the Montreal Canadiens and could provide the Oilers with the necessary stability over the next two years to really go for it and give Connor McDavid a chance at a Stanley Cup.


Canadiens Reportedly Have Their Eye On Oilers Prospect


Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Curtis Ault

I would not say no to Dylan Holloway for Edmundson either. I know he has had some injury issues, but watching Caufield at Wisconsin, you could not take your eyes off of Holloway.


Bourgault is good but we have too many Centers as is.
If they think he was NHL ready then i’d understand.
If he’s decent in the Faceoff Circle he could slot into Evans role once they trade Monahan and Dvorak/Evans move up to 2nd/3rd line roles again.

If they think he can step up he’s got good numbers for a 2 way Center.
Issue is im not convinced he is and we already have Centers pushed to wing now with Davidson, Roy, Kidney, Mesar, Beck,Guidon,Kappanen and Blondi all turning Pro in the next 2 years. They’re all either Top 10 Scoring Centers or Representing their nations with the exception on Blondi who’s Gallagher like in his style and will graduate univesity before age 21 where he’ll turn Pro. He’s extremely Physical and strong enough to play in the NHL with enough Bark to his Bite that he Draws a ton of penalties without taking more then 5-10 himself a year since entering the NCAA.

My Point is Bourgalt has till the end of the year if he ends up in MTL to take a spot or else he’ll likely be pushed out by Beck next year. TBH even if Bourgault overachieves i suspect Beck will push him out anyways as Slafkovsky-Beck-Mesar was the most comfortable ive seen Slafkovsky on any line this year where he looked like a hockey player not Bambi Falling all over the ice and getting out battled 1v1 along the boards.(in his defense he’s only ever been in the position Caufield’s in up top, he’s adjusting to a role he’s never been asked to play)

Montreal Hockey Now in your Inbox

Get the latest breaking news, opinion and analysis from the Montreal Hockey Now team directly in your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.